|
|
| Cleanliness of rooms |
| Facilities offered |
| Quality vs. Price |
| Location / Surroundings |
| Quality of service provided |
|
|
|
|
|
| Customer Rating [ Overall Average ] - 74 |
|
| 0 - 20 Very Poor |
20 - 40 Poor |
40 - 60 Average |
| 60 - 80 Good |
80 - 100 Very Good |
|
|
|
| Needs Tea/Coffee in bedrooms ... Hotel is Very central to all tourist attractions we enjoyed our stay and Would go back .. |
|
| Rating: 96% |
- Mark M , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
Hotel in right in the centre of the hussle and bussel of New York.
Madison Square Gardens and Macys Department store is on the door step.... click here to readmore >>
Hotel in right in the centre of the hussle and bussel of New York.
Madison Square Gardens and Macys Department store is on the door step of this hotel.
Rooms, staff and restaurants are amazing in thsi hotel.
I have stayed here five times and would return again.
I would hove no problem recommending this hotel to anybody. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 96% |
- Lily M , Ireland - |
|
|
|
this hotel is good value for the money and is so central to everything , times square just up the road , 5th ave two blocks away and of c.... click here to readmore >>
this hotel is good value for the money and is so central to everything , times square just up the road , 5th ave two blocks away and of course madison square gardens right opposite .we have stayed at this hotel for 8 times now and don't think we would go anywhere else unless they were full. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 84% |
- Maria W , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
rooms appear to be renovated since i last stayed there. seems there was a recent infestation of bed bugs but appears to be sorted. no sig.... click here to readmore >>
rooms appear to be renovated since i last stayed there. seems there was a recent infestation of bed bugs but appears to be sorted. no sign while i was there. same staff as my previous visit and they are very friendly.as always the location is perfect nice little cafe by reception for tea.coffee and snacks and delicious breakfast yoghurts. would stay there again << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 80% |
- Catherine O , Ireland - |
|
|
|
Please Enter the Comments / Review about the hotel in this area
The price of $ 391.00 for three nights is a gift. The room is old but c.... click here to readmore >>
Please Enter the Comments / Review about the hotel in this area
The price of $ 391.00 for three nights is a gift. The room is old but clean and comfortable. This hotel is very well located, have the opposite corner Penn Station and Times Square 5 minutes walk. To sleep in a hotel in New York is excellent. Thank you very much for the price.
Sent from my iPhone << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 84% |
- Orlando O , United States - |
|
|
|
The location of this hotel is excellent it is right opposite Madison Square Gardens and a stroll from Macy's. The hotel is quite big in f.... click here to readmore >>
The location of this hotel is excellent it is right opposite Madison Square Gardens and a stroll from Macy's. The hotel is quite big in fact I think it has the most rooms in NYC. There were four of us and we were upgraded to a large room with three double beds. The decor of the hotel corridors look like something you would see in a horror film quite dark and gloomy, to be honest the last thing you do in New York is stay in your room! Check In was efficient and pleasant considering it was Christmas therefore a very busy time for the hotel. On the ground floor is a 24 hour coffee shop great for when you come in from the cold! Macdonalds is a couple of doors down so it is very handy for breakfast, as are the deli's close by. All in all we had a great stay at The Pennsylvania, please don't go here if you are expecting 5* hotel. It has charm,is great value for money and fantastic location all in all a fab Christmas shopping break! << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Gemma H , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
Hotel was in a great location, next to Macys, opposite Maddison square gardens, and to blocks from The Empire State building.
Hotel was .... click here to readmore >>
Hotel was in a great location, next to Macys, opposite Maddison square gardens, and to blocks from The Empire State building.
Hotel was clean and friendly. Great diner in the lobby, Lindys. They serve a fantastic omelette and cheesecake to die for.
I have stayed here before in 1999, and would recommend it to any one. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 100% |
- Melanie P , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
| Excellent location, OK in all other aspects. Wouldn't mind stay there again next time in NY. |
|
| Rating: 72% |
- Poul F , Denmark - |
|
|
|
Brilliant location for all Mid town, down town facilities and transport. Hotel was easy to travel too, and the room provided was excellen.... click here to readmore >>
Brilliant location for all Mid town, down town facilities and transport. Hotel was easy to travel too, and the room provided was excellent for are needs, would stay there again. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 84% |
- Maxwell W , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
I have been here twice now all i can say is it is in a great location to all the sites. Right next to Penn Station so easy to get to furt.... click here to readmore >>
I have been here twice now all i can say is it is in a great location to all the sites. Right next to Penn Station so easy to get to further attractions.
Standard room's are a good size and if your going to do site seeing you will not be in the room that much.Shopping is right downstairs with Macy's, Old navy and the Manhattan mall with a 5 minute walk. Great price great location << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Christopher W , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
stayed here for 2 nitghts over st patricks day .hotel was fine.heard so much bad reports about so was a bit worried.for the price i paid .... click here to readmore >>
stayed here for 2 nitghts over st patricks day .hotel was fine.heard so much bad reports about so was a bit worried.for the price i paid for the 2 nights it was a bargin.i would recommend this hotel to anyone who just wants a cheap hotel in new york.nothing fancy about it.it did the job.room clean and bathroom clean.if your looking for a luxury hotel your going to pay top dollor for that in new york.if you just want a hotel to throw yoursrlf down after shopping r sightseeing this is the place for you << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 68% |
- Colin T , Ireland - |
|
|
|
the hotel is in an ideal location. the staff were more than helpful although there was a queue and a wait to check in. the rooms are basi.... click here to readmore >>
the hotel is in an ideal location. the staff were more than helpful although there was a queue and a wait to check in. the rooms are basic but very comfortable ,decor in need of updating. the mirror in our bathroom came away from the wall and the house hold supervisor on our floor was most helpful and immediately arranged for a room transfer. i would happily stay here again << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Catherine O , Ireland - |
|
|
|
Excellent location,beside Empire State Building,Macy's,Madison Square Gardens and Subway directly in front of hotel also Times Square onl.... click here to readmore >>
Excellent location,beside Empire State Building,Macy's,Madison Square Gardens and Subway directly in front of hotel also Times Square only 5 minute walk.Some of the reviews given were very unsatisfactory but I would have no hesitation staying here again.Rooms were a bit outdated and need to be more modernised but everything was clean and the hotel was right in the Heart of New York.We went in December and upon arrival it only took about 30mins to check in in such a busy time of the year. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 96% |
- Ronald F , Ireland - |
|
|
|
heater very noisy in room we moved to another room in this room the shower did not work so got moved again this room was ok reception ve.... click here to readmore >>
heater very noisy in room we moved to another room in this room the shower did not work so got moved again this room was ok reception very helpfull and apologetic rooms are very basic but clean not good value for money i think. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 52% |
- Vivian D , Ireland - |
|
|
|
very good location staff very helpful i will stay at the Pennsylvania on my next visit i have already recommended it to my brother i.... click here to readmore >>
very good location staff very helpful i will stay at the Pennsylvania on my next visit i have already recommended it to my brother in law and his family << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 100% |
- Marian S , Ireland - |
|
|
|
The Hotel Pennsylvania was excellent value, right in the heart of Manhattan. Ideally located for the tourist; easy and quick check-in and.... click here to readmore >>
The Hotel Pennsylvania was excellent value, right in the heart of Manhattan. Ideally located for the tourist; easy and quick check-in and out; reasonable room with an old-fashioned,but good bathroom and the biggest bed I've ever seen. The TV was large screen; and other failties were fine (iron, hairdryer etc.,)
Breakfast was small (orange juice, a coffee and a pastry) but very good quality. Staff were polite and helpful at all times.
Recommended! << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 88% |
- Eddie C , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
| hotel was ok,room was huge.Location of pennsylvania is brill,would stay again if going fir a short trip. |
|
| Rating: 72% |
- Susan P , Ireland - |
|
|
|
location of hotel was excellent. the service in the hotel was quite poor staff on concerige were rude and not friendly or much informativ.... click here to readmore >>
location of hotel was excellent. the service in the hotel was quite poor staff on concerige were rude and not friendly or much informative. ques in the hotel were long but it was a hotel so it wasnt hard not to expect that. Other than that I found it cheap easy located and comfortable so I would stay again. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 64% |
- Danielle L , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| staff were polite and helpfull , would highly recomend hotel |
|
| Rating: 96% |
- Ursula W , Ireland - |
|
|
|
This is the 6th stay at the Hotel Penn and as usual the service on arrival was good. The rooms are basic but clean but when in New York l.... click here to readmore >>
This is the 6th stay at the Hotel Penn and as usual the service on arrival was good. The rooms are basic but clean but when in New York little time is spent in the room, as long as the bed is clean ; comfy, what more could you want. For the price paid I don't believe you would get any better. The location is the hotel's best asset. It is right in the centre of Manhatton with easy access either by foot or by subway to all the attractions. We would always try to stay here as a first option (unless we won the lottery ; could afford a top class hotel) << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Carol D , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
location fabulous reception staff very helpful rooms not very pleasing on the eye but bedlinen and bathroom spotless my 3rd stay here and.... click here to readmore >>
location fabulous reception staff very helpful rooms not very pleasing on the eye but bedlinen and bathroom spotless my 3rd stay here and cant imagine staying anywhere else << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Denise B , Ireland - |
|
|
|
Perfect location if anyone is looking for a place to stay near macys its perfect..5 minute walk from tmes square !..ooms werenice except .... click here to readmore >>
Perfect location if anyone is looking for a place to stay near macys its perfect..5 minute walk from tmes square !..ooms werenice except for the carpets, they were very old ,not dirty just old ! << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 96% |
- Paula E , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| the bathroom sink was lose against the wall, rooms very basic but very big, overall very good |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Catherine J , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| very noisy rooms |
|
| Rating: 64% |
- V P , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
This was my fourth time staying at the Pennsylvania Hotel NY, each time through roomsnet. I have read many bad reviews about this place .... click here to readmore >>
This was my fourth time staying at the Pennsylvania Hotel NY, each time through roomsnet. I have read many bad reviews about this place on trip advisor but i can honestly say we have never had any problems when staying here and i would recommend this hotel to anyone who is just looking for a clean hotel room to rest their head after a long day of sightseeing and shopping. I wouldn't stay anywhere else in manhattan, the location is just fantastic, you have Madison Square Garden directly accross the road, Macys just one street to your right and down the side of the building the Manhattan Mall, Empire State Building is only two streets behind you also. Times square is only a 5min walk. There is also a great Irish pub The Blarney Rock accross from the side entrace, great place for breakfast in the morning. I really think this hotel is great value for money and if your not happy with your room just ask to be changed and i'm sure they would be more than accomodating. I have always asked for a renovated room on arrival and the room i have always gotten has been perfect. The rooms are small but what do you want, once you have a bed to sleep in, a tv to watch while unwinding at night and a lovely power shower to wake you up in the mornings i'm not sure what more you can ask for. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 100% |
- Glenda S , Ireland - |
|
|
|
The location of the Pennsylvania was ideal. The facilities offered were fine and the rooms although basic were clean and adequate. The .... click here to readmore >>
The location of the Pennsylvania was ideal. The facilities offered were fine and the rooms although basic were clean and adequate. The price was very competitive and I suppose it depends what you are looking for and what your budget is. There were 4 of us and we were in New York to see New York, not the inside of a hotel room, however we wanted a clean room with plenty of towels, hot water and comfy beds on our return. If you want luxury and plan to stay in the room more, then go somewhere else. This is my second time staying there and I would do so again. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 88% |
- Rose G , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
| Very basic hotel but location was excellent |
|
| Rating: 68% |
- Erica B , Ireland - |
|
|
|
the hotel was recommended to us by friends who had stayed there and we were really pleased with the hotel. We had a fantastic time in New.... click here to readmore >>
the hotel was recommended to us by friends who had stayed there and we were really pleased with the hotel. We had a fantastic time in New York and hope to be returning very soon! << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 92% |
- Christian A , France - |
|
|
|
I was dissapointed with the rooms. For a hotel in the middle of New York was very surprised. the rooms were very dated. what they need is.... click here to readmore >>
I was dissapointed with the rooms. For a hotel in the middle of New York was very surprised. the rooms were very dated. what they need is new furniture and fittings and new bathrooms all tiled.
The lobby of the Hotel was lovely. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 60% |
- Mary H , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| The hotel is very basic and could do with a revamp, but the location is brillant, close to everything. |
|
| Rating: 68% |
- Paul S , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| reception was slow checking in, only 2 on dutie at the time thats all. |
|
| Rating: 84% |
- David D , Ireland - |
|
|
|
stayed here in janurary, Hotel is in prime position on 7th avenue..Hotel could do with refurbishment as rooms are not a great standard.bu.... click here to readmore >>
stayed here in janurary, Hotel is in prime position on 7th avenue..Hotel could do with refurbishment as rooms are not a great standard.but all in all it is adequate. . . . . << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 80% |
- James Daniel S , Ireland - |
|
|
|
Hotel was quite shabby and room was not the cleanest and would not the best for couples/families but location is very central and price i.... click here to readmore >>
Hotel was quite shabby and room was not the cleanest and would not the best for couples/families but location is very central and price is pretty cheap. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 64% |
- Shane O , Ireland - |
|
|
|
this hotel is in a perfect location as macys is only a two minute walk.however, for the price paid the quality was very poor.this hotel i.... click here to readmore >>
this hotel is in a perfect location as macys is only a two minute walk.however, for the price paid the quality was very poor.this hotel is in real need of a refurbishment. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 64% |
- Ann D , Ireland - |
|
|
|
This hotel was very good value for money, it was in an ideal location close to some of the major sights, and the staff were friendly and .... click here to readmore >>
This hotel was very good value for money, it was in an ideal location close to some of the major sights, and the staff were friendly and helpful,the room was basic but clean and comfortable, if i was going to return to new york i would stay there again. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 80% |
- Kady R , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| Please note when a change of room was asked for nothing was provided.No fridge in the room or bath. |
|
| Rating: 72% |
- Andrew D , Ireland - |
|
|
|
We have stayed in hotels all over the world, and I can honestly say that this is by far the worst hotel we have ever experienced. The st.... click here to readmore >>
We have stayed in hotels all over the world, and I can honestly say that this is by far the worst hotel we have ever experienced. The staff were very un helpful, in fact they were almost rude. There were not enough staff on duty and we had to wait ages to get checked in and to get access to our saftey deposit boxes, one night I had to go out without my jewellery as I couldn't wait any longer. The rooms were in need of repair, the sink and the bath were full of cracks and the shower was all rusty. The paint was peeling of the walls and the lighting was so poor in the bedroom that we had to leave the toilet light on just to see what we were doing. When we came back one night there was dirty bed linen lying on top of our bed and the heating had been fully turned up. When we came back to pick up our luggage the day we were leaving, we asked where the toilets were in the hotel only to be told that the only toilets for the guest were in the rooms and as we had already checked out there was no where for us to go. I would never go back to this hotel and would never ever recommend it to anyone, in fact I would tell them to avoid it at all costs. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 44% |
- Rosemary Ann H , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
On arrival we asked for a room with a view and we were given a view of the Empire State Building. This was the best view we've had in th.... click here to readmore >>
On arrival we asked for a room with a view and we were given a view of the Empire State Building. This was the best view we've had in three visits to Manhattan. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 68% |
- Daniel W , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
| Fantastic staff and service, very friendly people. |
|
| Rating: 92% |
- Mairead H , Ireland - |
|
|
|
old styled rooms, very dingy, dirty bathroom, poor service..... BUT, brilliant location (about 2 mins from times square) plus cheaper tha.... click here to readmore >>
old styled rooms, very dingy, dirty bathroom, poor service..... BUT, brilliant location (about 2 mins from times square) plus cheaper than the majority and if you were like us and planned not to spend much time in the hotel, its good! << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 56% |
- Jonathan R , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
My first room 300A late Nov was dirty. I don't have anything good to say about that room. But next romm 466 early Dec was excellent also.... click here to readmore >>
My first room 300A late Nov was dirty. I don't have anything good to say about that room. But next romm 466 early Dec was excellent also service at reception was kind and good. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 68% |
- Juhani V , Finland - |
|
|
|
The hotel is perfectly situated for everything. We weren't very impressed with the first room they allocated us but it was no problem for.... click here to readmore >>
The hotel is perfectly situated for everything. We weren't very impressed with the first room they allocated us but it was no problem for them to change us to another room which was fantastic with a great view down 33rd to the Hudson river. We had fresh bed linen every day, with fresh towels everyday and even the heating switched on for us at 5.00 pm before we came in from a hectic days sight seeing - very impressed by this. The staff were all courtious throughout. Would definitely recommend it to others but beware of having a room on the front, which ours was, it can be noisy but then the whole of New York is. A very enjoyable holiday with no problems, many thanks to RoomsNet. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Peter R , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
The rooms are not particularly nice, but the location is great: suitable for those who are interested in having a place to sleep and show.... click here to readmore >>
The rooms are not particularly nice, but the location is great: suitable for those who are interested in having a place to sleep and shower and getting around rather than for those who want to stay in their rooms. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 60% |
- Sami L , Finland - |
|
|
|
I stayed in this hotel a few days ago ; I have to say I was completely ; utterly disappointed with my room. I stayed with a group who had.... click here to readmore >>
I stayed in this hotel a few days ago ; I have to say I was completely ; utterly disappointed with my room. I stayed with a group who had booked the Penn 500 option which included breakfast. The only advantage to this seems to be a superior quality room, as none of my group would eat the breakfast of buns, apples and coffee. I had booked the room only option preferring to breakfast with the locals in nearby diners. At no point was I informed that the Penn 500 option entitled you to a superior room. My room was appalling ; one of my friends insisted on staying with me. I will say the bed linen ; towels were clean, as was the bathroom ; the shower was one of the most powerful I have used. However the room was so worn ; used looking ; the overall cleanliness of it left alot to be desired, the dust on the surfaces was a long time gathering ; the carpet had not been vacuumed properly in what looked like months. The fridge in the room was filthy. I had heard from friends that the hotel was basic ; not the best ; I was prepared for that as the location being just down the street from Macy's and Times Square could not be beaten. But having paid ?390 for 2 nights at a room only rate I was shocked. I am from Ireland ; used to paying above and beyond for basic services, but if anyone walked into a hotel room in Ireland that was the same poor standard as my room in the Pennsylvania it would not be tolerated. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 40% |
- Shirley K , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| Execellent hotel have stayed here 8 times now. |
|
| Rating: 100% |
- Maria W , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
stayed at hotel from 13/1108 to 17/11/08. hotel was clean-fresh towels ; room cleaned daily. location was excellent. staff were friendly .... click here to readmore >>
stayed at hotel from 13/1108 to 17/11/08. hotel was clean-fresh towels ; room cleaned daily. location was excellent. staff were friendly ; helpful. if going to new york again would stay there no problem. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Mary H , Ireland - |
|
|
|
I stayed for 4 days and my opinion of the hotel was that of disappointment! THE ROOMS WERE SHABBY AND DATED !!!!! The clerk a the recepti.... click here to readmore >>
I stayed for 4 days and my opinion of the hotel was that of disappointment! THE ROOMS WERE SHABBY AND DATED !!!!! The clerk a the reception was less than helpful and ignorant. However as we were on a shopping holiday the location was perfect . Good area with with easy access to everywhere and close to 24 hour services! Also the resturuant ajoint to the hotel was expensive ! Overall I WOULD STAY THERE AGAIN SIMPLY FOR LOCATION AND WE DIDN'T STAY IN THE HOTEL ITSELF FROM WHEN WE GOT UP TIL WE WENT TO BED << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 40% |
- Padraig C , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| rooms were basic but clean. very good location. macys across the road great value shopping. |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Janet C , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| Ideal location,clean tidy,would go there again |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Anthony J , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
Hotel is centrally located, within walking distance to everywhere.
Room was basic but cleaned daily and sheets changed also during our 5.... click here to readmore >>
Hotel is centrally located, within walking distance to everywhere.
Room was basic but cleaned daily and sheets changed also during our 5 day stay << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 84% |
- Monica F , Ireland - |
|
|
|
The hotel is at a good location but the rooms could do with a major revamp the room left a lot to be desired. A warning to visitors do no.... click here to readmore >>
The hotel is at a good location but the rooms could do with a major revamp the room left a lot to be desired. A warning to visitors do not use the phone as the chareges are astronomical. I got chared 13.42 for a call that wasnt answered 3 calls made to a location in new jersey were charged at an international rate also. We werent told of this when registering.
Always long queues at reception not enough staff here. Otherwise we enjoyed our trip and got to see all the great sights. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 60% |
- Patricia C , Ireland - |
|
|
|
the hotel couldnt be more central if it tried, directly opposite madison square gardens and around the corner from macys/times square are.... click here to readmore >>
the hotel couldnt be more central if it tried, directly opposite madison square gardens and around the corner from macys/times square area. rooms were basic but cleaned daily with fresh towels daily, spent very little time in the room so location was key. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at the Pennsylvania NY. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 88% |
- Deborah O , Ireland - |
|
|
|
the location was great but the hotel was very dirty looking......could definately do with some touch ups. staff were not friendly or help.... click here to readmore >>
the location was great but the hotel was very dirty looking......could definately do with some touch ups. staff were not friendly or helpfull. would not recommend it << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 60% |
- Kathleen D , Ireland - |
|
|
|
My husband and myself stayed at this hotel for two nights, to celebrate our 20th anniversary. The hotel reception was bright and spaciou.... click here to readmore >>
My husband and myself stayed at this hotel for two nights, to celebrate our 20th anniversary. The hotel reception was bright and spacious and the receptionist whilst unfriendly was efficient. On arrival at the room, No 1463 we were shocked and horrified. It was tiny! The bed barely big enough for two people. The paintwork was crumbling and ancient around the door frame (the door was new and had obviously been recently installed). The carpet was nylon cheap quality and ill fitting. The wall beside the bed had a multiple stain (possibly blood or some other disgusting stain). The radiator was like something from the last century and beside it there was a pile of dust and rubble from where some type of "work" had been carried out. We pulled back the covers to check on the bed linen and this indeed was spotless. We were horrified so I rang reception and explained how upset we were. At first I was told all the rooms in the hotel were of the same standard, decor and size and when I offered to pay for an upgrade I was told that we could indeed be upgraded to a modernised revamped room for one hundred dollars plus taxes per night, but the room would still be the same "shoe box" size. The loo was spotless but tiny. We declined to pay the upgrade to a room of equal size as it was space we wanted. We would not recommend this hotel for anything but location. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 56% |
- Patrick O , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| Rooms dirty and not up to standard under 13th floor |
|
| Rating: 56% |
- Jennifer R , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| Great location, room dated but clean, would go back if i was staying in Manhattan |
|
| Rating: 88% |
- Paul M , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
First of all I was expecting the rooms to be bit more worthwild. The prices of the rooms are very expensive for a 2 star hotel. It is tho.... click here to readmore >>
First of all I was expecting the rooms to be bit more worthwild. The prices of the rooms are very expensive for a 2 star hotel. It is though very ideal location for tourists as Times Square and Empire State Building is a 5 minute walk away. Also, you have Madison Square Garden cross the road. It is best to book the hotel in your home country weeks in advanced and not book a room while your there. In short the rooms are OK but the facilities are very poor with not very nice wallpaper << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 56% |
- Steve C , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
Check in staff very rude. Charge you $4 per bag when your room is not ready and to store when you have checked out. Rooms particulaly tol.... click here to readmore >>
Check in staff very rude. Charge you $4 per bag when your room is not ready and to store when you have checked out. Rooms particulaly toliets are very old << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 40% |
- Chloe C , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
The Pennsylvania hotel was fantastic, it is in a great location, right opposite Madison Square garden, only 8 blocks down from Time Squar.... click here to readmore >>
The Pennsylvania hotel was fantastic, it is in a great location, right opposite Madison Square garden, only 8 blocks down from Time Square. The hotel was very clean and tidy, the staff were very helpful, my daughter is in a wheelchair and they were very helpful, there is a ramp and disabled lift into the lobby which is very spacious and 10 evevators to all the floors so you don't have to wait long to get to your room. The room was very clean, fresh bedding and towels every day, and air con which in the summer is a life saver.
I will definatly go back to the Penn << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 100% |
- Carolynne M , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
This was the 3rd time i have stayed in this hotel. The floor looked like it had dried paint on it, one of the lamps didn't work and the h.... click here to readmore >>
This was the 3rd time i have stayed in this hotel. The floor looked like it had dried paint on it, one of the lamps didn't work and the hot water was off. I did tell them at the desk and they fixed the lamp and the water was back on even though it was on and off. The location is perfect as you have a short walk to Chelsea and a bit further to Greenwich Village and the other way you have Time Square within a 3-5 minute walk. 5th Ave is a short walk too. I will come back to the hotel on my next visit down the the location. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 56% |
- Garry F , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
The best thing about the Pennsylvania Hotel is its location. It is right next to Macy's and only two blocks from the Empire State buildi.... click here to readmore >>
The best thing about the Pennsylvania Hotel is its location. It is right next to Macy's and only two blocks from the Empire State building. Penn Station is just across the road and this was really convenient this year, as we flew into Newark Airport and were able to get a train direct from the airport to Penn station, and just had to cross the road to get to our hotel. No taxi needed. On the other hand, when we did require to call a taxi (we were in new York for a wedding) there is a very helpful porter who hailed one for us using his very shrill whistle! The housekeeping service was excellent. Our room could have done with some minor refurbishmenta and the hotel has an air of faded glory, but it is reasonably priced, so I'm not complaining about that. We stayed there last summer and we recommended it to a group of our friends who went to NY for a shopping trip just before Christmas and they were quite satisfied with it too. Margaret ; Tony (mfranklin@eircom.net) << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 92% |
- Margaret F , Ireland - |
|
|
|
The decor of the hotel rooms was poor, it looked like they needed to be repainted. Linen was very clean, and lined change service excelle.... click here to readmore >>
The decor of the hotel rooms was poor, it looked like they needed to be repainted. Linen was very clean, and lined change service excellent.
The staff were absolutely brilliant. We had special needs due to an accident just before we visited, and they could not have been more helpful. Would stay again. Great central location. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Paul R , Ireland - |
|
|
|
Clean, quiet, couldn't get closer to the centre of Manhattan if you tried. Macy's next door, Penn Station across the road. Time square on.... click here to readmore >>
Clean, quiet, couldn't get closer to the centre of Manhattan if you tried. Macy's next door, Penn Station across the road. Time square only 2 minutes walk literally. Not luxury accommodation, but safe, friendly. Do not use the hotel phone very expensive even for local calls. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 88% |
- Enda C , Ireland - |
|
|
|
Hotel was in a great Location. Room was basic but exactly what we needed. Had a fab stay in new york. Staff very helpfull. Great place to.... click here to readmore >>
Hotel was in a great Location. Room was basic but exactly what we needed. Had a fab stay in new york. Staff very helpfull. Great place to stay. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 80% |
- Stephanie R , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
this is the third time i have stayed at this hotel.simply because of the location.Its so central and very good concerts are held in Madis.... click here to readmore >>
this is the third time i have stayed at this hotel.simply because of the location.Its so central and very good concerts are held in Madison square gardens which is right across the road.You can also get a great Irish breakfast in an Irish bar with a decent cup of tea also on the door step.Some of the rooms are shabby.but I always ask for a bigger airy room and have never been refused.The maid service is good and our bed sheets were cahnged daily also. Great price again because of the location.Would stay ther again. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 84% |
- Dorothy R , Ireland - |
|
|
|
Super location. Basic and clean room which was spacious with king size bed. TV Hairdryer and Iron provided. Large hotel so be prepared fo.... click here to readmore >>
Super location. Basic and clean room which was spacious with king size bed. TV Hairdryer and Iron provided. Large hotel so be prepared for queues at check in. Safety deposits available at reception but also required a long wait in line each time you wanted to go into it! Overall very good and would go back again. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 80% |
- Claire W , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
Rooms were basic but sheets and towels changed daily Furniture old but who spends a lot of time in their room in New York. Location is gr.... click here to readmore >>
Rooms were basic but sheets and towels changed daily Furniture old but who spends a lot of time in their room in New York. Location is great right in the heart of the city. Empire state building just 2 blocks away Madison square garden and Maceys next door. Greyline Tour bus stops outside Maceys. Times square 20 minute stroll away. For the price we were delighted with this hotel. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Clive B , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
Asked for a room on the 3rd fl as have stayed in this hotel before. Hoever, was placed on the 10th fl in a front room that was very noisy.... click here to readmore >>
Asked for a room on the 3rd fl as have stayed in this hotel before. Hoever, was placed on the 10th fl in a front room that was very noisy. It is in an excellent location however it is old and basic. I would stay in this hotel again but not in a front room as its too noisy. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 72% |
- Catherine R , Ireland - |
|
|
|
VERY GOOD LOCATION.
ROOM BETTER THAN EXPECTED BUT TOLD I HAD A NON SMOKING ROOM
DID SMELL OF SMOKE COULD NOT CHANGE.
CHAOTIC AT CHECKI.... click here to readmore >>
VERY GOOD LOCATION.
ROOM BETTER THAN EXPECTED BUT TOLD I HAD A NON SMOKING ROOM
DID SMELL OF SMOKE COULD NOT CHANGE.
CHAOTIC AT CHECKIING IN DESK ---- TOO MANY PEOPLE !!!!!
VERY EXPENSIVE TO USE HOTEL PHONE --- FIVE MIN.LONG DIST.
CALL ---- 39 DOLLARS !!!!!!!!!!!!! << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 72% |
- David M , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
Staff were very friendly and helpful. Location was ideal. Rooms were basic and clean. Restaurant down stairs was not great. Ideal place t.... click here to readmore >>
Staff were very friendly and helpful. Location was ideal. Rooms were basic and clean. Restaurant down stairs was not great. Ideal place to stay for seeing the sights and shopping! << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 80% |
- Deirdre W , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| We had a very enjoyable time and the service was very good. |
|
| Rating: 20% |
- Rocco C , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| Good hotel, great location and would definetly go back. |
|
| Rating: 84% |
- Daniel W , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
i found people to be very help full. i have stayed in the pennsylvania three times in all and have enjoyed each trip. thank you for a ple.... click here to readmore >>
i found people to be very help full. i have stayed in the pennsylvania three times in all and have enjoyed each trip. thank you for a pleasent stay and would like if you could send me any offers you have on as i am going again next feb. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 88% |
- Diana M , Ireland - |
|
|
|
The Pennsylvania was an idel hotel for loction to everthing in new york.When we arrived we had red all the reviews and to be honest a bit.... click here to readmore >>
The Pennsylvania was an idel hotel for loction to everthing in new york.When we arrived we had red all the reviews and to be honest a bit scared, but when i was checking in i asked for an up grade and we got it , the room was very basic nut cleenand warm which is what we needed as it was very cold. If i was to be asked were you could stay in new york id be saying there, we have booked for next year and we will bestaying there again , so dont beleve everthing you read the hotel is good for the amount of time you spend it so book it << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 72% |
- Norman G , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| i think the hotel rooms could be alot cleaner |
|
| Rating: 60% |
- Noeleen M , Ireland - |
|
|
|
Enjoyed my stay immensely. Sheila, on reception was most helpful. I am extremely grateful to her and please pass on my thanks to he.... click here to readmore >>
Enjoyed my stay immensely. Sheila, on reception was most helpful. I am extremely grateful to her and please pass on my thanks to her.
I did think that the lighting was quite poor. As a matter of fact, I had a small kettle with me and it seemed as if it took it forever to boil. It did not in any way spoil my break. Thanks again. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 88% |
- Caroline R , Ireland - |
|
|
|
Hotel was in a great location. Rooms were badly in need of refurbishment. Bedding and towels were changed every day but some staff were m.... click here to readmore >>
Hotel was in a great location. Rooms were badly in need of refurbishment. Bedding and towels were changed every day but some staff were more helpful than others. However we did not spend much time in the hotel as thre was so much to do and see in New York. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 56% |
- Pamela M , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
The one double room I stayed in was very small but it wasnt an issue as I was out most of the time. The room had a large TV which feature.... click here to readmore >>
The one double room I stayed in was very small but it wasnt an issue as I was out most of the time. The room had a large TV which featured all the major news channels and tourist information channels. The hotel had WiFi (not free), although it was only available in the lobby. There was a small computer room which was great because on the last day I checked in to British Airways and printed off my boarding pass.
The best part about staying at Hotel Pennsylvania is the location! Times Square is a 5 minute walk and so is Macys and the Empire State building.
In all the hotel deserves a high 4 out of 5 stars!
For photos and video of my trip to New York which was in November 2007 visit my blog: http://tollerton.blogspot.com << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Shaun T , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
JUST BACK FROM NEW YORK. THERE WAS 8 IN OUR PARTY WE HAD 4 ROOMS IN THE PENNSYLVANIA. WE WERE ALLOCATED THE 3RD FLOOR. IT WAS LIKE GOING .... click here to readmore >>
JUST BACK FROM NEW YORK. THERE WAS 8 IN OUR PARTY WE HAD 4 ROOMS IN THE PENNSYLVANIA. WE WERE ALLOCATED THE 3RD FLOOR. IT WAS LIKE GOING BACK IN TIME. THE ROOMS WERE DAMP AND THE PLASTER FALLING OF THE WALLS. WE ASKED TO BE MOVED AND WE WERE ALLOCATED THE 5TH FLOOR. WE HAD TO PAY EXTRA TO BE UPGRADED.THE ROOMS WERE SMALLER BUT NOT AS DAMP. WE LATER FOUND OUT THAT THE 3RD FLOOR IS WHERE THEY PUT THE DOWN AND OUTS OF NYC. WOULD NOT USE roomsnet.com AGAIN AS I FEEL WE WERE MISS LEAD WITH THE ACCOMODATION. THE RECEPTIONIST TOLD US THAT THEY BOOK THE VERY BASIC ROOMS IN THE HOTEL.AT LEAST IF WE HAD A CHOICE OF PRICES WHILE BOOKING WE COULD CHOOSE FOR OURSELVES. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 60% |
- Sharon L , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| Hotel is very basic but clean. It's location is brilliant very central for all shopping. Coreen Ireland |
|
| Rating: 60% |
- Coreen M , Ireland - |
|
|
|
great location, rooms very basic and falling apart,would do for roughing it for a few days but no palace, on par with regents palace in .... click here to readmore >>
great location, rooms very basic and falling apart,would do for roughing it for a few days but no palace, on par with regents palace in london(old and run down soon as you go upstairs but brillant location << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 72% |
- David P , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
| Hotel in excellent location, very central. Rooms basic, but clean. Take a room above the 10th floor if possible. |
|
| Rating: 68% |
- Marie R , Ireland - |
|
|
|
very disappointing hotel in very poor state and generally staff not to helpful. Paint peeling off ceiling and wallpaper likewise. First t.... click here to readmore >>
very disappointing hotel in very poor state and generally staff not to helpful. Paint peeling off ceiling and wallpaper likewise. First time disappointed with a hotel in the US after many visits << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 40% |
- Mary G , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
| Some Hotel Staff very rude. In the rooms,the paint on the walls was falling off. Room deco was very very bad. Do not recommend Hotel |
|
| Rating: 52% |
- Susan D , Ireland - |
|
|
|
We chose the pennsylvania hotel, because some of our friends had stayed there before.The hotel is in a great location, the rooms are a bi.... click here to readmore >>
We chose the pennsylvania hotel, because some of our friends had stayed there before.The hotel is in a great location, the rooms are a bit grubby, rooms are crying out for a coat of paint but the beds are very clean and comfey. Lots of white towels, every day. Staff very nice, there is a great bar with some very good music. I would go back again. Everything on the doorstep of the Pennsylvania. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 72% |
- Eugenia N , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| The hotel even though it is old is a great location and the staff were lovely,always friendly and polite,many thanks Ann Marie D`Arcy. |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Annmarie D , Ireland - |
|
|
|
The hotel was very centrally located for our needs, very busy with nationalities from hundreds of countries. We were situated on the 10th.... click here to readmore >>
The hotel was very centrally located for our needs, very busy with nationalities from hundreds of countries. We were situated on the 10th floor and found it quiet. Disappointments were that it had no facilities for making tea or coffee and alcohol was not allowed in the rooms.Should i return to New York i will certainly consider this hotel again. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 80% |
- Conor O , Ireland - |
|
|
|
My better half and I stayed here Sept 07,read some scary reviews! the rooms are a bit dated and the bathroom a bit old,but come on we had.... click here to readmore >>
My better half and I stayed here Sept 07,read some scary reviews! the rooms are a bit dated and the bathroom a bit old,but come on we had a view of empire state building, your in the middle of everything and for the price would not hesitate to stay again.If you are planning on staying in your room for your duration book the Hilton,if not you can't beat this.
rooms cleaned daily.Ignore the scary reviews and book it << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 80% |
- Colin D , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
Hotel in ideal place to sightsee, the rooms are very basic could do with a complete overall to bring them upto date, peeling paint, stain.... click here to readmore >>
Hotel in ideal place to sightsee, the rooms are very basic could do with a complete overall to bring them upto date, peeling paint, stained wallpaper, carpet very poor. We complained about condition of room and they moved us the next day after 3.00pm two floors up but the room was not much better. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 60% |
- Margaret W , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
Stayed here for the second time (Sept 2007), previous visit Oct 2006. Had a massive room this time on the 2nd floor, very clean and very .... click here to readmore >>
Stayed here for the second time (Sept 2007), previous visit Oct 2006. Had a massive room this time on the 2nd floor, very clean and very central for seeing the sights. Check in time was protracted because of the number of people, they were evidently booking in 600 people that day with only about five staff! This is an ideal venue if you want a bed and a bathroom for the night. Macy's store is just around the corner, you are opposite Maddison Square Gardens and a ten minute walk from the Empire State Building. Take an open top bus ride to see the sights, we had excellent guides real New Yorkers. Pre book tickets for the Empire State Building and Statue of Liberty/Ellis Island. ENJOY! Jan New Malden << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 84% |
- Jan D , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
Shortage of reception staff meant long delays at the reception desk and also when using the safe deposit box system. However the hotel .... click here to readmore >>
Shortage of reception staff meant long delays at the reception desk and also when using the safe deposit box system. However the hotel is ideally placed a very short walking distance to Times Square etc. We walked everywhere even to Central Park. The hotel is old and tatty but I would recommend its locality as when in New York you spend such little time in your room the location is the most important so you can get out and about easily and see the City!! << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 56% |
- Diane H , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
| Excellent location. basic room very impresive lobby. Would I stay there again......YES |
|
| Rating: 72% |
- Cecil G , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
THE HOTEL WAS BASIC BUT MET OUR NEEDS, IT WAS CLOSE TO MOST ATTRACTIONS AND THE STAFF WERE VERY HELPFUL. OUR FAMILY ROOM WAS VERY LARGE .... click here to readmore >>
THE HOTEL WAS BASIC BUT MET OUR NEEDS, IT WAS CLOSE TO MOST ATTRACTIONS AND THE STAFF WERE VERY HELPFUL. OUR FAMILY ROOM WAS VERY LARGE AND WE DID NOT FEEL WE WERE CROWDED. IT WAS A VERY BUSY HOTEL WITH LOTS OF PEOPLE AROUND ALL THE TIME, WE WOULD STAY THERE AGAIN. IT WAS ACROSS THE ROAD FROM MADISON SQ GARDEN. WE WOULD ALSO USE roomsnet.com AGAIN IT WAS SO EASY AND QUICK TO BOOK. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 60% |
- Ayer D , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
I stay at this hotel 3 times a year and have come to know the place very well. Don't get me wrong if what you are after is luxury then th.... click here to readmore >>
I stay at this hotel 3 times a year and have come to know the place very well. Don't get me wrong if what you are after is luxury then there are alternative options. However, the location is greater than any other hotel in Manhattan. You are seconds away from the 1,2 and 3 trains, Penn Station, B,F,D,V,N,R,Q and W Trains are a block away at Herald Square {Macy's too} and the A,C and E trains are a block away on 8th Avenue. The whole of New York is effectively at your doorstep. May I add that the added convenience of having the greatest Deadly Buffalo Wings on the planet just seconds away at Gyro/Spinellis Pizza on 7th is the icing on the cake.
The staff is friendly in particular the duo of Yen and Shahid are value for money on there day. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 96% |
- Matthew B , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
This hotel is a great location very central a vew blocks from times square, madison gardens on your doorstep subway 1 block away. Room a.... click here to readmore >>
This hotel is a great location very central a vew blocks from times square, madison gardens on your doorstep subway 1 block away. Room are basic no frills but cleanen every day but when in New York you dont spend much time in your room as there is so much to do and see. We found the information desk brillant very helpfull with booking tours and taxi bus back to the airport. also web acess on ground floor for check in for your return flight home if booked on the web. bar and resturant in the hotel not badly priced. we really enjoyed our stay. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 84% |
- Janet P , Ireland - |
|
|
|
| overall not bad, but boy could this place do with a facelift beyond the foyer |
|
| Rating: 76% |
- Carmel D , Ireland - |
|
|
|
Please ensure there is at least tea and coffee facilities in the bedrooms and ensure the toliets are cleaned or decorated. Rooms were ver.... click here to readmore >>
Please ensure there is at least tea and coffee facilities in the bedrooms and ensure the toliets are cleaned or decorated. Rooms were very dusty and were not cleaned once during my stay. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 48% |
- Barbara D , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
i feel that there should have been tea and coffee facilities in the room, espically if they are not offering breakfast. The rooms were ex.... click here to readmore >>
i feel that there should have been tea and coffee facilities in the room, espically if they are not offering breakfast. The rooms were extremely dirty, therefore i would not be staying here again or recommend. << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 48% |
- Lynne C , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
The Hotel was absolutely brilliant. The room was cleaned was very clean and tidy. it was cleaned and new towels every day. Great service..... click here to readmore >>
The Hotel was absolutely brilliant. The room was cleaned was very clean and tidy. it was cleaned and new towels every day. Great service. Hotel also located exactly where it said it was located ``in the middle of everything``. this was right opposite penn station in the centre of new york. great service thanks very much << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 92% |
- James W , Ireland - |
|
|
|
on first arival, this hotel look's first class, the reception is lovely and clean. once you have checked into your room, then the standar.... click here to readmore >>
on first arival, this hotel look's first class, the reception is lovely and clean. once you have checked into your room, then the standards drop. even the security staff that we spoke too admitted they get 100's of complaints, but there attitude was "if yoou can find somewhere as cheap in as good of location, then best of luck" seeing that we were 3 lad's on a short break, it wasn't that much of an issue, but i don't think i would ever take my girlfriend there << click here to read less |
|
| Rating: 56% |
- Bryan W , United Kingdom - |
|
|
|
