Guest Reviews for New York Inn - New York

we were very disapointed in the hotel the location was good as it is right near Times square but as for the rooms, they were filthy and i believe we could have got a much better place for the price, also whilst we were there someone tried to kill themselves from the same building and someone was threatening to stab a man right outside our room in the middle of the night. not only that but half way through our stay we found pest traps all around our room. most of the rooms were tiny and dirty eventually on our move to the third room it got slightly better almost barable.

MY STAY AT THIS HOTEL WAS DISTRESSING I WOULD NOT MAKE A RECOMMENDATION TO ANYBODY TO STAY HERE. RATS WERE FOUND IN BOTH ROOMS WE STAYED IN, I HAD AN ITEM OF CLOTHING STOLEN FROM MY ROOM THAT MANAGEMENT WERE NOT PREPARED TO DO ANYTHING ABOUT. I LEFT MY HOUSE KEYS IN MY ROOM ON DEPARTURE WHICH I EMAILED MANAGEMENT TO FORWARD ON, MY EMAIL WAS COMPLETELY IGNORED. I COULD GO ON BUT NEED I SAY MORE!! KATHARINE ABBEY

THE HOTEL WAS DREADFULL, THE ROOMS WERE TINY FOR 2 PEOPLE VERY DIRTY. WE HAD TO MOVE ROOMS AFTER 2ND NIGHT AS THERE WAS EITHER A MOUSE OR RAT IN OUR ROOM. WE CHECKED OUT A DAY EARLY SO HAD TO PAY FOR ANOTHER HOTEL JUST TO HAVE A GOOD NIGHT SLEEP AND A CLEAN BATH. HOW THIS IS PASSED AS A HOTEL AMAZED ME.

if you want a nice comfy place to stay in new york do not go here. if on the other hand you simply need a place to leave your bags then go ahead. i spent five nights here with my brother and only because we spent very very little time in the room i wouldve demanded my money back. we are both average height/build guys but one of us had to sit on the bed if the other needed to pass between beds to get to toilet. (which is rediculously small) our window view was a brick wall. we were on fourth floor with no elevator and the staff were very moany. like i said only stay if you literally need a room to leave your gear!

This has been one of the worst stays I've ever had. There were shouting in the hall ways through the night, 2 of my 4 nights I did not have hot water, and one night, after my return from site seeing, a body was carried out by 2 medics. Not the place you want to stay.

The room was a bit small but was air conditioned and cleaned daily (fresh towels etc.). It was right in the centre of downtown Manhattan, just a short walk from Times Square. Would have liked a safe either in the foyer or in room, but as it was, none of our important documents were taken.

The hotel is not what we expected. We were led to believe that it had recently been refurbished but this was patently not the case. The location was good, however, had it been my wife travelling with me instead of my son, there is no way she would have agreed to have stayed !!