Guest Reviews for Milford Plaza - New York

The hotel is situated in the perfect position for the theatre district etc. easy accessability to the shopping blocks and the subway (tube for us english). The room is adequate if you anly want somewhere to sleep although should you wish to spend time in your room it is comfortable and very clean. The overall decor is shabby with peeling wallpaper etc. I laughed when I read in the lift that we are to modernise our hotel and we thought not before time.. They then quote its the hotel lifts and not anywhere else!! Overall a worthwhile stay. Security is excellent too....... Kim & Alex

I had stayed in this hotel before and found it to be ok although a no frills hotel, it has gone downhill badly, was booked in for 2 nights, but only stayed 1 and had to leave, the rooms were tiny , dirty, and extremely shabby, will not be recommending or staying in this hotel again.

On our second visit on the night of 3rd June, we were put in Room 652. This room was appalling - the air conditiioning unit did not work, the shower could not be regulated, two electrical sockets were hanging from the wall in a dangerous condition and the room was in a poor state of decor. We complained to the manager when we left the following morning who took down details and told us to inform you of the problem so that you can arrange compensation through their accounting system. Lynda Poole

after three rooms and beig very tired we were over all discusted, the first room had been prised open several times before (gouges in woodwork) keys didnt work, shower didnt work, the 2nd room no hot water, the third room the facilities worked we were told we were upgraded its equivalent to b and b in uk except the b 8 b in uk would probably be more modern. the first impression was superb and thats as far as the superb went. the toilet bowls in all three rooms had been scratched so badly they were black at the bottom the tile grouting was mouldy in all three bathrooms. the dust behind the beds hadnt been touched for months, electric cables to lights were in a tangled heap, health and safety here would have a ball, curtains did not shut and were for decor only the blind was not sufficient for privacy or noise levels. I t is the worst hotel I have ever stayed in my life that is to include bed and breakfasts stop overs in uk. the sheets were cleaned daily because we tipped daily! we had been upgraded to receive breakfast which after one visit was enough! very old fashioned and in desperate need of upgrading, The first nigh the wife cried her eyes out with disgust.

Please Enter the Comments / Review about the hotel in this area This was the first time to New York. Didn't no what to expect. Hotel very clean, affordable and staff very helpful. Location brilliant. Would recommend to friends and would definately stay their again.

Please Enter the Comments / Review about the hotel in this area great location 1 block from time square.problem with the shower it kept cutting out which wasnt ideal half way through a shampoo.Room was very hot couldnt open the window as the window was jammed.other wise it was ok.went to st patricks day parade it was great.Linda from cork ireland

This hotel offered very distinct advantages and disadvantages. WE BELIEVED THE ADVANTAGES OUTWIEGHED THE DISADVANTAGES. The main problem was noise - there were approximately 40 floors and we were situated on 4th and there seemed to be sort of 'water hammer' or air lock in the bathroom pipes that was activated whenever anyone above us turned the water on - the noise level fluctuated but it was definitely loud enough to rouse you from a very deep sleep - this coupled with the single glazed window which admitted street noise from the city that never sleeps caused much sleep disturbance - however - New York keeps you very busy by day and we found that we were tired enough to go back off to sleep very easily and I am not a good sleeper at the best of times. Also the room was the smallest I've ever stayed in but it was well equipped with iron and ironing board, telly, big illuminated clock for night-time, safe and hairdrier. I have to say that the room and bathroom were SPOTLESS almost immaculate when taking into account the overall age of the accomoodation. We read all the reviews before booking and were not put off by lack of food and beverage facilities as anything and everything - all the variety in the world - is available just a few steps outside. The distinct advantage is the location of this hotel as you can do whatever you like then just trot home - no need for transport unless of course you are going any distance. We will definitely go back - ENJOY